Skip to content
-
Subscribe to our newsletter & never miss our best posts. Subscribe Now!
What's Up Movies What's Up Movies What's Up Movies
What's Up Movies What's Up Movies What's Up Movies
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy
  • T & C
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Privacy
  • T & C
Close

Search

Film Analysis & Theory

The Hollow Echo of True Crime: A Critical Post-Mortem of ‘Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story’

By Iffa Jayyana
September 18, 2026 6 Min Read
0

The Ryan Murphy-produced Monster anthology on Netflix, which began as a lightning-in-a-bottle examination of Jeffrey Dahmer, has officially devolved into a repetitive, listless exercise in historical reenactment. With the release of its fourth season, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, the franchise has reached a creative nadir, signaling that the "prestige true crime" subgenre may finally be running on fumes.

What was once a platform for interrogating the dark corners of the American psyche has, by this latest installment, become a self-referential loop that seems wholly disinterested in its own existence. While previous seasons at least attempted to grapple with the media frenzy surrounding their subjects, The Lizzie Borden Story relies on superficial tropes and a disjointed meta-narrative that leaves the viewer with little more than a headache and a sense of profound déjà vu.

The Evolution of an Anthology: From Dahmer to Borden

The Monster franchise was retroactively and somewhat awkwardly dubbed as such to establish a surprise hit as the foundation of a broader, thematic anthology. After the massive cultural footprint of Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, the show’s creators sought to broaden the lens to include other American icons of infamy. John Wayne Gacy and Ed Gein were folded into the narrative, and the second season, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, pivoted toward the L.A.-centered media obsession of the 1990s.

By the time the franchise reached its third and fourth iterations, the ambition had shifted from psychological depth to a sort of "serial killer cinematic universe." Season 3, which focused on Ed Gein, even flirted with a meta-narrative featuring iconic horror figures like Norman Bates, Buffalo Bill, and Leatherface. The inclusion of Aileen Wuornos in the fourth season—played by Sarah Paulson—feels like the final, desperate attempt to bind these disparate stories together under a thin, feminist-coded veneer.

‘Monster,’ the TV Show, Devolves Into a Poor Impersonation of ‘Monster’ the Movie

Chronology of a Failed Narrative

The narrative structure of The Lizzie Borden Story is, by design, fractured. It attempts to weave together the 19th-century tale of Lizzie Borden with the 20th-century story of Aileen Wuornos, while also making room for historical "special guest stars" like the Hungarian aristocrat Elizabeth Báthory.

The story focuses on the suffocating household of Andrew (Charlie Hunnam) and Abby Borden (Rebecca Hall). Andrew is presented as a quintessential villain: a funeral parlor owner who profits from the misery of the bereaved and harbors a bizarre obsession with fitting cadavers into undersized caskets. Abby, meanwhile, is a caricature of domestic malice—throwing boiling soup at servants and demeaning her step-daughter with a cold, articulate cruelty.

The show introduces the "Aileen Wuornos" thread in the fourth episode, where the serial killer is portrayed as a devotee of the Borden legend. She is shown reading about Lizzie, communing with her spirit in an attic, and viewing her as a "soul sister" who succeeded where Wuornos failed: by literally getting away with murder. This connection is not rooted in history—there is no evidence that Wuornos ever considered Borden a muse—but rather in the showrunners’ desire to force a thematic link between female rage across different centuries.

Supporting Data and Production Values

Despite its thematic shortcomings, the show boasts high production values and a cast that is largely wasted on the script. Rebecca Hall’s performance as Abby Borden is arguably the season’s only saving grace. Her portrayal of a domestic tyrant is cartoonish yet compelling, providing a rare moment of dark, campy levity in an otherwise dreary slog. When a poisoned bowl of seafood leads to a sequence of projectile vomiting, the show briefly flirts with the kind of grotesque, black-humored brilliance that made earlier seasons of Ryan Murphy’s work so memorable.

‘Monster,’ the TV Show, Devolves Into a Poor Impersonation of ‘Monster’ the Movie

However, Ella Beatty’s performance as Lizzie is notably blank, and Charlie Hunnam’s Andrew is too archetypal to evoke any real menace. The decision to cast Vicky Krieps as both the maid, Bridget, and the 16th-century "Blood Countess" Elizabeth Báthory creates a confusing visual shorthand that the script never bothers to fully explain or justify.

The historical parallels drawn by the series are, at best, clumsy. By equating the systemic oppression faced by a Victorian-era socialite with the desperate, violent survivalism of a modern-day sex worker, the show flattens the nuance of both.

Official Responses and Creative Intent

The creative team, led by Ian Brennan, has maintained that the Monster franchise is intended to be an investigation into the "why" of murder, rather than a mere glorification of the acts themselves. In interviews surrounding the release, the production team highlighted the systemic failures—of justice, of gender, and of class—that define the lives of these killers.

Yet, there is a disconnect between this stated intent and the product on screen. Where the 2003 film Monster, starring Charlize Theron, achieved an "embodiment" of Aileen Wuornos that invited empathy without excusing violence, this series feels like a shallow, "bug-eyed" impression of that same work. The show repeats the arguments of twenty years ago without adding anything new to the conversation, resulting in a product that feels less like a historical investigation and more like a retread of better, more sensitive art.

‘Monster,’ the TV Show, Devolves Into a Poor Impersonation of ‘Monster’ the Movie

The Implications of "True Crime" Fatigue

The primary failure of The Lizzie Borden Story is its reliance on the rhetorical question: "Who is the real monster here?" It is a question the show has asked with diminishing returns in every season. By this fourth entry, the question has become a shield for lazy writing.

The implications for the true-crime genre are significant. As streaming services continue to churn out dramatizations of real-world atrocities, the audience is increasingly left to grapple with the ethics of "entertainment-fying" suffering. When a series like Monster uses real trauma to fuel its narrative, it has an obligation to provide more than just aestheticized violence or superficial commentary on the patriarchy.

The show’s attempt to frame Lizzie Borden as a proto-feminist icon—using her acquittal as a vehicle to discuss suffrage and independence—is, at best, a radical distortion of history and, at worst, an insulting take on the feminist movement. It implies that the ultimate form of female empowerment is the ability to kill one’s abusers, a reductionist view that feels particularly hollow given the complexities of the real-life cases.

Conclusion: The Verdict

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is a D+ effort that marks a low point for the franchise. It is a show that can no longer justify its own existence through the lens of social commentary or character study. It has become an impression of its own former self—a stylistic exercise that lacks the heart, the bite, or the intellectual rigor of its predecessors.

‘Monster,’ the TV Show, Devolves Into a Poor Impersonation of ‘Monster’ the Movie

For those interested in the complexities of female rage and the true-crime genre, there are better, more incisive works to explore. Furious, for instance, provides a much sharper, more modern take on the themes Monster attempts to tackle but ultimately fails to grasp.

As for Monster, it is perhaps time for the anthology to return to the shadows. After four seasons, the monster has been stripped of its mystique, leaving behind only the wreckage of a story that, quite frankly, didn’t need to be told this way.


Grade: D+

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is currently available to stream on Netflix.

Tags:

AnalysisbordencrimecriticalCriticismechoFilmStudyhollowlizziemonstermortempoststoryTheorytrue
Author

Iffa Jayyana

Follow Me
Other Articles
Previous

A Half-Century of Glamour and Grit: The Enduring Legacy of "Charlie’s Angels"

Next

A Cinematic Testament: The Musical Tapestry of ‘Daniel and the Fiery Furnace’

No Comment! Be the first one.
The Spell is Cast: ‘Practical Magic 2’ Ends ‘Spider-Man’s’ Historic Box Office DominanceBridging Reality and the Upside Down: The VFX Mastery of Stranger Things Season 5The Summer of the Shark: Why ‘The Devil’s Mouth’ Is Defying Critical Backlash to Become a Global Streaming PhenomenonBlood, Heat, and High-Stakes Politics: Hulu’s ‘City of Blood’ Promises a Dystopian Reckoning in BerlinThe Future of the Frame: Anurag Kashyap on Authenticity, AI, and the Evolution of Cinema at MIFFestThe Resurrection of the Infamous: Inside the Definitive 4K Restoration of ‘Cannibal Holocaust’A Fifty-Year Haunting: Reassessing Brian De Palma’s Obsession and the Fractured Vision of Paul SchraderThe Evolution of Miles Teller: From Hollywood Prodigy to Dramatic HeavyweightReturn to Altair IV: The Definitive 4K Restoration of the Sci-Fi Masterpiece Forbidden PlanetCinematic Portraits of a Drifting Generation: Martina Buchelová’s “Lover, Not a Fighter”

You May Have Missed

Film Awards & Oscars

The Unsung Architects of Cinema: Highlights from the 15th Annual Hamilton Behind the Camera Awards

Pevita Pearce
By Pevita Pearce
November 17, 2026
Celebrity Gossip

The Art of the Outerwear Transition: Navigating the Season’s Most Coveted Coat Trends

Basiran
By Basiran
November 16, 2026
Fan Culture

Beyond the Lagoon: The Forgotten Reunion of Gilligan’s Island Stars on The Wild Wild West

Sagoh
By Sagoh
November 16, 2026
Movie Trailers

The Weight of History: A Deep Dive into Antonin Baudry’s Epic ‘De Gaulle’ Duology

Muslim
By Muslim
November 16, 2026
Box Office Reports

Global Box Office Report: Johnny Depp’s ‘Ebenezer’ Claims the Crown in a High-Stakes Weekend

Laily UPN
By Laily UPN
November 16, 2026
Film Analysis & Theory

The Mechanics of a Heist: Why Apple TV+’s ‘12 12 12’ Struggles Under the Weight of Its Own Complexity

Layla Zulfa
By Layla Zulfa
November 16, 2026
Fan Culture

The Scrooge Resurgence: What "Ebenezer" Signals for Johnny Depp’s Hollywood Future

Reynand Wu
By Reynand Wu
November 16, 2026
Horror & Genre

The Scoop of the Century: Clint Howard Returns to His Most Chilling Role in ‘Another Ice Cream Man’

Ali Ikhwan
By Ali Ikhwan
November 16, 2026
South Indian Cinema

"Itllu Arjuna" Arrives: A Bold Debut Navigating Love, Crime, and the Power of Silence

Neng Nana
By Neng Nana
November 13, 2026

Actor Analysis Awards BackgroundScore Cannes Celebrity Cinema Analysis cinematic cinematography Composers Creative Criticism Critics Culture director Fandom Festivals FilmStudy Geeks Genre Gossip Horror Industry Kollywood Lifestyle Music netflix OST Pop Culture PopCulture Previews Production Ratings Regional Cinema Reviews SciFi Screenplay South India Sundance Teasers Theory thriller Tollywood trailers Upcoming

Copyright 2026 — What's Up Movies. All rights reserved. Blogsy WordPress Theme